8. What’s your favourite character of the book? (You CAN’T cheat like me, it must be JUST ONE) Fingon
6. Would you have followed Fëanor? Yes.
16. What do you think of Fingolfin going to attack Melkor? Brave but stupid. But I loved him for it.
Me too! For the last one. Thank you!Â
I forgot to answer “17.”Â
17. You are Fëanor and YOU HAVE the silmarils (Melkor didn’t take it). Would you give them to Yavanna save the two trees and bring light to Valinor again? Probably not. Clearly, it was a hysterical request since the Valar were able to solve the problem later once they had calmed. And Feanor believed, probably correctly, that breaking apart the Silmarils would kill him. Kind of like destroying Sauron’s one ring.
The whole Pepsi commercial thing reminded me that people always mis-remember the famous flower in the gun barrel photo as being a young woman. It wasn’t. The photo, taken by Bernie Boston, is of George Edgerly Harris III better known by his stage name Hibiscus. He was a member of the San Francisco based radical gay liberation theater troupe the Cockettes. He died of AIDS in 1982 at the time AIDS was still referred to by the name GRID which stood for Gay Related Immuno-Deficiency. The photo was taken at a protest at the Pentagon.Â
I had no idea who he was, thank you.
This is one example of the Mandela Effect phenomena, where an iconic moment is reenacted with a hippy woman so many times that people think that’s the story and thus another gay man is written out of history. Thanks for the photo.
I had no idea. Wow.
This photo was taken by Bernie Boston, a black/native man who willingly stood up to a chapter of the KKK and earned their respect among other things
I get the subject is important, but please dont erase Bernie. I knew him personally and he deserves to be remembered and by only remembering the subject, a white man, you erase a black man.
@vaspider could you reblog this version too, please? I am deeply upset by Bernie’s erasure from his own work.
OMG! The Pepsi ad is so gross, revolting and a trivialization of people who put themselves in harm’s way at anti-Vietnam-war demos, time and time again. And were not paid for it (unlike Kendall Jenner).
It is very interesting how people remember history. An earlier use of the symbolism of the flowers vs. guns was at demonstrations at UC Berkeley (1965) and shortly thereafter spread around the country. It was a couple of years later that there were a few captures of that image at one of the big demonstrations at the Pentagon. Among photos taken that days was the Pulitzer Prize-winning photo by Bernie Boston of George Edgerly Harris III 21 October 1967.Â
The one above was another famous photo circulated internationally –  taken same day, the same demonstration of 100,000 people in D.C. – by French photojournalist Marc Riboud 21 October 1967 March on the Pentagon of a 17-year-old female high school student named Jan Rose Kasmir. Nobody was copying anyone in the case of those iconic photos.Â
Here is another photo taken that same day– October 21, 1967 – same March on the Pentagon. (Photo by S.Sgt. Albert R. Simpson)
Also, Bread and Puppet Theater in New York City staged numerous protests during that period which included handing out balloons and flowers to armed forces (military, national guard, and police). I personally recall witnessing several young women at UC Berkeley sticking flowers into guns around that same time–not me! I never placed myself that close to a gun barrel, I wanted to live to protest another day. And I thought the “flower power” concept was bullshit at the time–naive and apolitical. But that was me–I was hardcore serious about my politics.
So the statement that “people always mis-remember the famous flower in the gun barrel photo as being a young woman” is accurate if one assumes they are recalling the Bernie Boston photo, but there were many other similar photos and some included young women. Bernie Boston got a Pulitzer prize so his was perhaps the best known at the time, but not the only flower-power photo which received wide circulation and attention.
2. What’s your favourite elf (can be Noldor or not)?
3. What’s your favourite dwarf?
4. What’s your favourite Valar?
5. What’s your favourite man of the First Age?
6. Would you have followed Fëanor?
7. Glaurung or Ancalagon?
8. What’s your favourite character of the book? (You CAN’T cheat like me, it must be JUST ONE)
9. Discuss Maeglin’s actions and motives.
10. Which King of NĂşmenor is your favourite?
11. Do you agree with the way the Valar dealt with Middle-earth?
12. Doriath or Nargothrond?
13. A character you don’t like and why.
14. What’s your favourite Maiar?
15. Would you trust Ossë?
16. What do you think of Fingolfin going to attack Melkor?
17. You are Fëanor and YOU HAVE the silmarils (Melkor didn’t take it). Would you give them to Yavanna save the two trees and bring light to Valinor again?
18. What do you think Eru meant by “And thou, Melkor, shalt see that no theme may be played that hath not its uttermost source in me, nor can any alter the music in my despite. For he that attempteth this shall prove but mine instrument in the devising of things more wonderful, which he himself hath not imagined.”?
19. Who do you think had the worse destiny: HĂşrin or TĂşrin?
20. If you could be a character from the book which one would you choose?
21. What do you think of Melkor considering all since the song?
22. If you could marry one of Fëanor’s sons which one would you choose?
23. What do you think of Eöl?
24. Why do you think that the race of men are the only one that never went to Valinor besides the orcs?
25. What’s your favourite Age?
26. Imagine Sauron falls in love with you but you love Melkor who loves no one (seriously that little shit). What do you do?
27. What do you think it was the most evil deed of Melkor?
28. Would you prefer to fight against Gothmog (the balrog of course) or Glaurung?
29. If you were an elf in Midlle-earth after the War of Wrath would you sail immediately to Valinor or wait a little more in Middle-earth?
30. What do you think of the fact that Tolkien created in 360-ish pages something so perfect and complex?
Here’s to the fanfic writers who can only write sporadically.
Here’s the writers who can’t output enough to keep up with the most popular writers.
Here’s to the writers writing even though they get no feedback.
Here’s to the writers who somehow manage to scrape together a little inspiration and a lot of hard work to write that story they know nearly no one will read.
Here’s to the creators who keep going even when it’ feels like screaming into an empty void.
You’re inspiration, and I don’t know how you do it.
Please share this. I’m scared to death that because the internet’s so focused on the US, that saving net neutrality in Canada won’t get as much attention or support